Charles Codman, Entertainment of the Boston Rifle Rangers by the Portland Rifle Club in Portland Harbor, August 12, 1829, 1830

Rufus Porter, Art, and Enterprise in Portland, Maine

Laura Fecych Sprague
Around 1800, Rufus Porter (1792–1884) and his family moved from Boxford in northeastern Massachusetts to Pleasant Mountain Gore in Maine, which remained a district of Massachusetts until Maine achieved statehood in 1820. Like thousands of other Massachusetts residents, Rufus’s father, Tyler Porter (1757–1842) took advantage of land made available by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts after the Revolutionary War. He purchased holdings in western Cumberland County and actively participated in the region’s development. By 1811, Rufus had moved into Portland, a leading seaport and Cumberland County’s seat.1 With its thriving economy, the town inspired and supported him as he launched his remarkable career. From 1811 until his departure in 1819, Porter pursued activities in the three fields for which he would later become well known: painting, inventing, and publishing. This essay describes Portland’s cultural life and some of the itinerant artists, entrepreneurs, and mechanics who were also developing their skills and expanding their spheres of patronage in the early 1800s. It expands on ideas presented in Rufus Porter’s Curious World: Art and Invention in America, 1815–1860, edited by Laura Fecych Sprague and Justin Wolff, and co-published in 2019 by the Bowdoin College Museum of Art in association with the Pennsylvania State University Press. An exhibition of the same name was on view at the Bowdoin College Museum of Art through May 31, 2020.
Lemuel Moody, Signals at Portland Lighthouse / 1807 / Signals Belonging to Merchants of Portland, 1807.
Fig. 1 Lemuel Moody, Signals at Portland Lighthouse / 1807 / Signals Belonging to Merchants of Portland, 1807. Watercolor and pen and ink on paper, 20 9/16 x 16 1/2 in. (62.2 x 41.9 cm) Collections of Maine Historical Society, 67-811-7

Rufus Porter was raised on Moose Pond in today’s Bridgton, northwest of Sebago Lake and thirty-eight miles from Portland. In 1804, when Rufus was twelve, his father enrolled him at Fryeburg Academy in Fryeburg, Maine. This private day and boarding school established in 1792, and still in operation today, was about nine miles west of Porter’s home. Amos Jones Cook, the Academy’s progressive headmaster, was an inspirational figure: he published The Student’s Companion, a compilation of works by celebrated authors and poets; employed the power of music in the education of his students; and assembled a renowned cabinet of curiosities for his charges.2 Porter readily found intellectual stimulation in spite of his frontier location. He later fondly recollected that his family’s farm was “beautifully variegated with woodlands, high and steep hills, miry grass-marshes, level plains, sand banks, running brooks, and a small pond; also a large orchard, . . . cider-mill, . . . mechanical implements of agriculture, and a workshop in which they were made and repaired.” He especially enjoyed “drawing sketches, floating a boat, or running a miniature cart” and “excelled in drawing and music; having made a small fiddle about that time.”3 Tyler Porter’s business operations included a sawmill and the development of a canal in the waterways near Sebago Lake. As a boy, Rufus “learned to construct not only miniature water-wheels and saw-mills, but water-power trip-hammers, and a variety of complicated mechanical movements.” He came into Portland as a teenager “for a season” to work on board ships in the harbor.4

Charles Codman, Entertainment of the Boston Rifle Rangers by the Portland Rifle Club in Portland Harbor, August 12, 1829, 1830
Fig. 2 Charles Codman, Entertainment of the Boston Rifle Rangers by the Portland Rifle Club in Portland Harbor, August 12, 1829, 1830. Oil on panel, 24 1/2 × 32 1/2 in. (62.2 × 82.5 cm). Brooklyn Museum, Dick S. Ramsay Fund, 51.196.
Porter’s move to Portland was a natural progression for the ambitious and talented young man. Like the rest of the District, the town’s population grew dramatically after the Revolutionary War. Familial, commercial, and political networks tied Portland and the rest of Maine to Boston and towns throughout eastern Massachusetts. Commerce, shipping, and shipbuilding drove a booming economy for entrepreneurs and artisans; international trade brought increased prosperity to many. A retired sea captain, Lemuel Moody (1761–1846) expressed this vitality in his Signals at Portland Lighthouse / 1807 / Signals Belonging to Merchants of Portland (Fig. 1). He had devised a signaling system with merchants’ flags at the Observatory, an eighty-two-foot-high octagonal tower built in 1807 on Munjoy Hill. He was especially proud of his telescope made by the Dollands, England’s leading optical firm. When he spotted ships offshore, Moody flew the merchants’ flags from the cupola to alert owners of their vessels’ arrival. Moody’s drawing not only identifies the individual flags but also depicts the ship channel and approach to the harbor. While offering important communications for the maritime community, the Observatory was a form of entertainment for many others. Moody welcomed visitors to climb to the cupola, at the cost of twenty-five cents, where they were rewarded by views of Casco Bay to the east and the White Mountains with majestic Mount Washington, New England’s highest peak, seventy miles to the west.5 Munjoy Hill also provided open space for the parade grounds, later depicted by Portland landscape painter Charles Codman (1800–1842) in his Entertainment of the Boston Rifle Rangers by the Portland Rifle Club in Portland Harbor, August 12, 1829 (Fig. 2).
Alexander Parris, Edward Preble House, 1805
Fig. 3 Alexander Parris, Edward Preble House, 1805. Ink, ink wash, watercolor on paper, 9 13/16 x 7 11/16 in. (24.9 x 19.5 cm). Courtesy, American Antiquarian Society, Mss octavo volumes P.
Alexander Parris, Front View of Portland Bank, 1806
Fig. 4 Alexander Parris, Front View of Portland Bank, 1806. Ink, ink wash, watercolor on paper, 9 13/16 x 7 11/16 in. (24.9 x 19.5 cm). Courtesy, American Antiquarian Society, Mss octavo volumes P.

A beloved landmark that survives today, the Observatory was constructed as part of Portland’s redevelopment following the town’s destruction in 1775 by a British naval bombardment. Other new and notable commercial and residential buildings in the federal style were the work of Alexander Parris, a young architect from Pembroke, Massachusetts, who developed many innovative classical designs for residents. In 1805, Parris designed a three-story brick dwelling with a low hip roof for Commodore Edward Preble (Fig. 3). The home’s entrance faced the side street, enabling a large double parlor to run across the principal Congress Street elevation. Parris’s facade for the Portland Bank built in 1806 featured semicircular arches on the ground floor with applied pilasters on the upper elevations. Sky-lit interior stairs and groin vaulting made this the town’s most sophisticated example of federal commercial architecture (Fig. 4). Although immensely talented, Parris faced the financial adversities caused by the Embargo of 1807. He soon left to expand his horizons, pursuing a notable architectural career, first in Richmond, Virginia, and then in Boston.6

In addition to improving their built-environment, Portlanders also supported societal organizations, including the Maine Charitable Mechanic Association (MCMA), founded in 1815 to educate men whose livelihoods were derived from their manual or skilled labor (known as mechanics) and “promote inventions and improvements in the Mechanic Arts.”7 Marcus Quincy, a town officer, was one of the MCMA’s founders. At his store on the waterfront, he “attend[ed] to the painting business” and is credited with teaching Rufus Porter “the trade of a house painter.” Porter himself observed that he “commenced learning the house and ship painting, . . . [and] was a ready-made sign and ornamental painter.”8 Porter’s endeavors may have further benefited from an extended group of relatives in town, including cousin Aaron Porter (1752–1837), a physician who helped develop Porterfield Plantation in western Maine, which was incorporated as the town of Porter in 1807. His wife, Paulina King Porter (1759–1833) was the sister of Rufus King (1755–1827), a leading United States politician, and half-sister of William King (1768–1834), who became Maine’s first governor.9

George Bailey, Portland Light Infantry Muster, ca. 1803 painted in 1846
Fig. 5 George Bailey, Portland Light Infantry Muster, ca. 1803 painted in 1846. Oil on canvas, 19 5/8 x 23 5/8 in. (50 x 60.2 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society and Maine State Museum, 1998.30.2
Probably painted by Charles Hubbard, side drum, 1824
Fig. 6 Probably painted by Charles Hubbard, side drum, 1824. Maple and calfskin, diam.: 20 × 17 in. (50.8 × 43.2 cm). Museum of Fine Arts, Boston; William Francis Warden Fund, 2015.2925. Photograph © 2019 Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

In March 1811 Portland Light Infantry, a private militia company, enrolled Rufus as a new member. Rufus participated in regular musters on Munjoy Hill and target practice in Deering Oaks, part of the Deering estate nearby on Back Cove. He recollected that “being a musician in a first-rate uniform company of infantry, and having been previously for some months in regular service at a fort, I was sometimes employed in teaching a fife and drum school.”10 The Portland artist George Bailey later depicted the company’s activities in a delightful painting of an encampment (Fig. 5). Within a rural landscape filled with white tents, uniformed militia members mingle with happy spectators. Horses, carriages, and musical instruments can all be seen. A side drum, with decoration attributed to Charles Hubbard (1801–1876) of Boston, illustrates the type of percussion instrument that Porter would have played (Fig. 6). Its painted design depicts the Seal of Massachusetts surrounded by flags and trophies of war.

Company members also inspired Porter in the field of invention and mechanical improvements. John Hancock Hall (1781–1841), its lieutenant, was working on a breech-loading rifle that he patented in 1811. His innovative mechanism enabled more efficient loading of the gun, and his concept of interchangeable parts transformed the early arms industry. After winning a contract with the United States armory, Hall left Portland in 1819 for Harpers Ferry, Virginia, the site of one of America’s two arsenals and armories, where he produced thousands of rifles between 1820 and 1840. Within fifteen years, Porter would design his own innovative gun mechanism. He never patented his revolving rifle but sold the concept to Connecticut arms manufacturer Samuel Colt in 1836.11

Michele Felice Corné, Bombardment of Tripoli
Fig. 7 Michele Felice Corné, Bombardment of Tripoli. Oil on canvas, 36 11/16 x 48 1/16 (80.5 x 122.0 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, A86-803
The arts in Portland were on the rise and exhibitions appeared in temporary venues. At Union Hall, a large exhibition space, residents took in the Bombardment of the City of Tripoli, a sixty-foot long panorama “executed in a masterly stile” by Michele Felice Cornè (1752–1845). Italian-born, Cornè emigrated to Massachusetts in 1800. From his base in Salem, he found patronage for his portraits, decorative wall murals, and other works. Celebrating the young United States Navy’s achievement in the war against Tripoli, the scene was especially meaningful for Portland because native son Edward Preble had commanded the fleet, defeating the Barbary pirates in 1803. The panorama was only available for viewing for “a short time” in April 1807, probably a few weeks. Its popularity, however, warranted a return visit and it was on view again in August 1808.12 Preble had commissioned his own painting of the bombardment from Cornè in 1805 (Fig. 7), which furnished his neoclassical residence designed by Alexander Parris (see Fig. 3). In 1816, Stowell and Bradley advertised their “Elegant Museum,” a temporary exhibition on display where Portlanders marveled at a life-size wax statue of George Washington, a “Temple of Industry; or Grand Mechanical Panorama” with dozens of moving figures, and landscape views by the “most eminent American artists.”13
John Roberts, Elizabeth Wadsworth, 1803
Fig. 8 John Roberts, Elizabeth Wadsworth, 1803. Watercolor on ivory, 2 1/2 x 2 in. (6.4 x 5 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, A90-37
John Roberts, Stephen Longfellow,1803
Fig. 9 John Roberts, Stephen Longfellow,1803. Watercolor on ivory, 2 1/2 x 2 in. (6.4 x 5 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, A90-86
Unidentified artist, John Quinby, ca. 1800
Fig. 10 Unidentified artist, John Quinby, ca. 1800. Watercolor on ivory, 2 1/8 x 1 3/4 in. (5.6 x 4.7 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, 2494*5
Local residents also increased their patronage of individual artists. Those who traveled, such as sea captains or legislators, might embrace an opportunity to have their portraits taken while away. For example, Captain Joseph McLellan, Sr., commissioned Henry Sargent (1770–1845) of Boston to paint his portrait in 1798.14 For residents based in Portland, itinerant artists offered a variety of styles at a wide range of prices, from as much as $100 for an oil portrait to twenty-five cents for a cut-paper silhouette. Itinerant artist John Roberts (1769–1803) advertised in Portland’s newspapers from August 1801 to March 1803, offering full-sized and miniature portraits in addition to ceremonial Masonic aprons. A native of Scotland, Roberts actively pursued a multi-faceted career as an artist, engraver, and inventor following his emigration to America in 1793. He painted the portrait of Elizabeth (called Betsey) Wadsworth in October 1801 on a fine sheet of ivory (Fig. 8). Her sister Zilpah asked a friend, “Should you like to see Betsey’s miniature? I hope to have it in my power to show you a very good likeness though I can not say as yet how good it will be, for it is not finished. It is taken by Roberts.” Roberts offered a reduced price of $10 for three miniatures, if taken together. He likely painted the portrait of Stephen Longfellow, Betsey's betrothed, at the same time (Fig. 9). Roberts’s work is noted for his simplified depiction of dress and his large, distinctly drawn eyes. Sadly, Betsey Wadsworth died of consumption before she and Stephen could be married, but her likeness remained as a treasured memorial.15 Shipbuilder John Quinby (1758–1806), a successful merchant in the Atlantic trade (Fig. 10), commissioned an as-yet unidentified artist with a more refined style to paint his miniature-on-ivory portrait.
William King, Zilpah and Stephen Longfellow, ca. 1805
Fig. 11 William King, Zilpah and Stephen Longfellow, ca. 1805. Negative cut on paper with embossed mark, 7 5/8 x 10 1/4 in. (19.5 x 26 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, A 85-197
Portlanders also took advantage of silhouette cutters, who offered an inexpensive way to capture a likeness. William King (working 1804–1809) from Salem, Massachusetts, visited Portland in 1805, advertising that he had “taken about 10,000 likenesses in Salem, Newburyport, Portsmouth, & their ajoining [sic] town.” A pair of silhouettes celebrated the union of Stephen Longfellow and Zilpah Wadsworth, who were married in 1804 following Betsey's death (Fig. 11). He embossed the paper “W. King” below the shoulder of the sitter. In hollow-cut or negative profiles, such as these, the silhouette was cut from white paper and placed over a black background. Some silhouettists cut a positive image instead, applying a solid profile to a contrasting ground. King advertised that he used his “patent delineating pencil.” His fee was twenty-five cents to create two profiles of the same person, and his special mechanical device likely sped his task. Zilpah’s parents, Elizabeth and Peleg Wadsworth, also commissioned silhouettes at this time, perhaps taking advantage of the group discount that King also offered.16
John Brewster, Jr., Moses Quinby, 1806-1810
Fig. 12 John Brewster, Jr., Moses Quinby, 1806–1810. Oil on canvas, 30 in. x 25 in. (76.2 cm x 63.5 cm). Bowdoin College Museum of Art, gift of Mrs. Candace E. Quinby Maynard, 1950.15
Attributed to John Brewster, Jr., Prentiss Mellen, 1800–10
Fig. 13 Attributed to John Brewster, Jr., Prentiss Mellen, 1800–10. Watercolor on ivory, 2 11/16 × 2 1/16 in. (6.8 × 5.2 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, 1851*-1
John Brewster Jr. (1766–1854), an artist from nearby Buxton, and several yet-to-be identified artists created compelling portraits–full size in oil-on-canvas or miniatures on ivory. In 1806, Brewster advertised in the newspaper and many of his portraits of Portlanders are known.17 He was another artist who used mechanical devices to help speed the process and improve the accuracy of the likeness.18 In 1806, John Quinby’s son Moses (1786–1857) graduated from Bowdoin College, twenty-seven miles north of Portland. Maine’s first, the college was established in memory of James Bowdoin II, former governor of Massachusetts, with the aid of his son, James Bowdoin III, expressly to educate Maine residents. Following his graduation, Moses returned to Portland to study law with Stephen Longfellow. He inherited his father’s estate after John’s death in September 1806, and, as a young attorney, commissioned his waist-length oil-on-canvas portrait from Brewster (Fig. 12). Brewster depicted him neatly attired in a forthright, focused way. His was one of three Quinby oil portraits attributed to Brewster that were still on view in the family’s historic Stroudwater homestead in the early twentieth century.19 One of Brewster’s rare miniatures depicts Harvard College-educated Prentiss Mellen (Fig. 13), who had settled in Portland by 1806 and built a new house on State Street, another of Alexander Parris’s elegant federal-style dwellings. Early in his law career, Mellen was a circuit rider; he later served as a legislator and eventually became Chief Justice of the new state in 1820.20
Detail, Stroudwater Light Infantry Company banner. 1805
Fig. 14a Detail, Stroudwater Light Infantry Company banner. 1805. Painted silk, 57 5/16 x 71 7/8 in. (146.4 x 182.5 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, 4284*
Unidentified artist, Stroudwater Light Infantry Company banner, 1805
Fig. 14b Unidentified artist, Stroudwater Light Infantry Company banner, 1805. Painted silk, 57 5/16 x 71 7/8 in. (146.4 x 182.5 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, 4284*
Several Massachusetts-based artists gained important Portland commissions. For example, James Akin (ca. 1773–1846), an engraver from Newburyport, created the membership certificate for the Portland Marine Society in 1807. Composed of foliate cartouches of maritime scenes, Akin’s design is closely related to Joseph Callendar’s 1789 engraving for the Boston Marine Society.21 Akin had just earlier engraved the Perpetual Almanack in 1805 for Gardner Goold, Rufus Porter’s neighbor in Pleasant Mountain Gore. This large engraving clearly presented vital daily information–days of the week, sunrise, and sunset. It likely inspired Porter, who developed an especially innovative Revolving Almanack after he moved to Boston.22 The Stroudwater Light Infantry Company, another of Portland’s private militias, also commissioned an out-of-town Massachusetts artist for their new silk banner (Fig. 14a). Given its exceptional quality, the painter was likely Boston-based, and possibly John Ritto Penniman, one of New England’s most accomplished ornamental painters. In 1805, Eunice Quinby (1783–1862), daughter of John Quinby, presented it to the company. On the obverse, a soaring eagle with a shield, clutching arrows and an olive branch, is inscribed Presented to the Stroudwater Light Infantry / From the Fair to the Brave. The custom of ladies (the Fair) presenting banners to militia companies is well documented in early America.23 The reverse features the Seal of Massachusetts enclosed by its official motto: Ense Petit Placidam Sub Libertate Quietem (translated from the Latin as “By the sword we seek peace, but peace only under liberty.”) (Fig. 14b). Rufus Porter may have known and, as the accomplished painter he was, admired this important Portland banner.
John Neal, Specimen / of / Penmanship / by / J. Neal / Vive La Plume!, ca. 1813
Fig. 15 John Neal, Specimen / of / Penmanship / by / J. Neal / Vive La Plume!, ca. 1813. Ink on paper, 12 3/4 x 9 1/2 in. (32.4 x 24.1 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, John Neal Collection, Coll. 2125

In 1807, Congress passed the unpopular Embargo Act, prohibiting shipping and trade with Britain and France, and Portland’s commercial progress was temporarily curtailed. Even in these tough economic conditions, young artists and entrepreneurs sought ways to generate income by their talents. As a teenager, John Neal (1793–1876), one of Porter’s contemporaries, excelled at penmanship and maintained merchants’ ledger books. After meeting traveling penmanship master William W. Rockwell in 1811, Neal traveled to Bowdoin College and central Maine, giving penmanship and watercolor lessons and creating ink portraits.24 With his Specimen of Penmanship, ca. 1813, inscribed “Vive La Plume!,” Neal celebrated his creativity and engaged potential clients (Fig. 15). This ambitious young man soon left Maine to promote American artists, including Washington Allston (1779–1843) and Samuel F. B. Morse (1791–1872), and published America’s first art criticism in Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine in 1824 and 1825.25

Unidentified artist, View of Portland Harbor, Cushing’s Island and Fort Scammel from Fort Preble, 1853-1862
Fig. 16 Unidentified artist, View of Portland Harbor, Cushing’s Island and Fort Scammel from Fort Preble, 1853–1862. Oil on canvas, 10 1/2 x 15 (26.7 x 38.1 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, A86-825

Many years of Porter’s residency were dominated by activities related to the War of 1812. During this anxious time, Portland struggled to get Massachusetts to send military support, a major factor in residents’ renewed push for statehood after peace was declared late in 1814. Hundreds of militia volunteers moved in and out of Portland, serving short terms in companies. They improved two state forts: Fort Sumner on Munjoy Hill, just north of the Observatory, and Fort Burrows below at Fish Point on the Fore River. Architect Alexander Parris superintended the construction of two new federal forts—Preble and Scammel—that guarded the ship channel. A painting of Portland’s harbor illustrates how these structures appeared before they were enlarged in 1862 (Fig. 16). Fort Preble, honoring Commodore Edward Preble, who died in 1807, was on the south side of the Fore River near shipyards. Fort Scammel, named for Alexander Scammell, a Revolutionary War hero, is visible on the island at the center of the picture. Volunteer militiamen worked on these forts, and others served on privateers that forayed from the port. This may have been when Porter was “employed on board armed vessels, [when] I acquired some knowledge of marine discipline, as well as sailor’s duty,” as he recollected. During the war, the British invaded and occupied Castine in Penobscot Bay, a twenty-four-hour sail to Portland. Their skirmishes in other coastal towns raised a serious threat to Maine, and Portland prepared for war. Porter served as musician and played the fife and drum in Captain Nathaniel Shaw’s Company, Lieutenant Colonel M. Nichols’s Regiment. Raised at Portland and serving from September 7 to 19 and, again, from September 26 to October 3, 1814, it included members of the Portland Light Infantry. Later that fall, from November 5 to 26, 1814, Porter served again as a musician with Lieutenant Oliver Bray’s Detached Company at Fort Burrows.26 This palisaded structure is visible in the lower right of Codman’s encampment painting (see Fig. 2).

Portlanders, Porter among them, personally experienced one of the war's most dramatic naval engagements. On September 5, 1813, the brigs USS Enterprise and the HMS Boxer engaged in battle off the coast of Maine, resulting in a stirring American victory. Tragically, however, the young American and British captains were both mortally wounded. The damaged ships were brought into Portland harbor, and the town arranged a double funeral. On September 9, following an elaborate cortège, the captains were buried side-by-side in the Eastern Cemetery on Munjoy Hill. As a militia musician and member of Captain Shaw’s company, Porter may well have participated in the solemn military procession.27

After peace was declared on Christmas Eve 1814 with the Treaty of Ghent, cultural activities resumed. Porter’s militia experiences inspired his first known attempt in publishing: a Martial Musician’s Companion, a compendium of instructions for the drum and fife. While looking for a collaborator, he wrote to Charles Norris in February 1815. Norris was the same New Hampshire publisher who Porter’s headmaster, Amos Cook, had corresponded with a few years earlier, and Cook likely made the referral. Although Porter secured his copyright, he was unable to negotiate the book’s financing and it was never printed. This failure did not discourage his future efforts, however, for in another five years Porter found support for his first arts manual, known familiarly as the Curious Arts, published in Concord, Massachusetts, in 1820–1821.28

A new book of particular interest to Portlanders was Abel Bowen’s The Naval Monument, his major work of 1816 that commemorated American achievements during the War of 1812. Bowen created engravings of the principal battles, including the Enterprise and Boxer, based on oil paintings by Michele Felice Cornè. In the years ahead, Abel and his brother Henry Bowen would collaborate with Porter on some of his new endeavors.29

William Bache, Francis Douglas, ca. 1815
Fig. 17 William Bache, Francis Douglas, ca. 1815. Cut paper with watercolor; embossed mark, 4 3/4 x 3 3/4 inches (12.0 x 9.5 cm.). Collections of Maine Historical Society, 2022
William Bache, Mary L. Deering, ca. 1817
Fig. 18 William Bache, Mary L. Deering, ca. 1817. Cut paper with watercolor; embossed mark, 6 1/2 x 5 3/8 in.  (16.5 x 13.3 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, 2001.203.002
Unidentified artist, Seth Clark, ca. 1815-1820
Fig. 19 Unidentified artist, Seth Clark, ca. 1815–1820. Watercolor on ivory, 2 1/2 x 2 1/8 in.  (6.5 x 5.3 cm). Collections of Maine Historical Society, A 67-172-39
Unidentified artist, Mary Owen Elder, ca. 1817
Fig. 20 Unidentified artist, Mary Owen Elder, ca. 1817. Watercolor on ivory, 2 3/4 x 2 5/16 (6.9 x 5.9 cm).Collections of Maine Historical Society, 4323
Itinerant artists returned to Portland. English-born William Bache (1771–1845) immigrated to Philadelphia about 1793 and later worked in many cities on the east coast. From February to May 1815, he advertised his services in Portland. He cut the likeness of Francis Douglas (ca. 1783–1820), editor of the Eastern Argus, one of the papers in which Bache’s notices appeared. Perhaps he bartered the profile in exchange for his published notices (Fig. 17). The negative-cut, white-paper profile was placed on a black ground. He added brushed details to the hair and white highlights delineate the shirt ruffle and coat. Bache also took the profile of Mary Louisa Deering (1805–1878), daughter of James Deering (Fig. 18). Its negative cut is highlighted in the same way with painted details of her hair, tendrils around her face, and a ruffled collar. Both works bear his embossed mark “BACHE'S / PATENT” on the lower edge of the shoulder.30 Two small watercolor portraits of Seth Clark (1783–1871) and Mary Owen Elder (1802–1838), accomplished works on ivory by unidentified artists, reveal the level of quality that Portlanders sought (Figs. 19 & 20). After his War of 1812 service, Clark helped establish the Maine Charitable Mechanic Association and became the town’s first merchant tailor. His account book reveals many of his clients, including Amos Cook and Prentiss Mellen, but not the painter who captured a compelling likeness of an engaging young man. Clark is set off on a light blue ground, nattily dressed in a blue coat and red waistcoat. Taken in a three-quarter view, Mary Owen Elder, the daughter of a baker, is attired in a high-waisted white dress typical of the period, complete with decorative blue sash, red shawl, and curled hair held by a comb.31
John G. Brown, Southwest View of Bowdoin College, circa 1823
Fig. 21 John G. Brown, Southwest View of Bowdoin College, circa 1823. Oil on canvas, 30 1/8 in. x 37 1/8 in. (76.52 cm x 94.3 cm). Bowdoin College Museum of Art, Gift of Harold L. Berry, Class of 1901
Frans Francken III, attributed to, Achilles at the Court of Lycomedes, ca. 1650
Fig. 22 Frans Francken III, attributed to, Achilles at the Court of Lycomedes, ca. 1650. Oil on panel, 20 7/16 in. x 31 11/16 in. (51.9 cm. x 80.5 cm.). Bowdoin College Museum of Art, Bequest of the Honorable James Bowdoin III, 1813.2
Gilbert Stuart, Thomas Jefferson, 1805–1807
Fig. 23 Gilbert Stuart, Thomas Jefferson, 1805–1807. Oil on canvas, 48 1/2 in. x 39 7/8 in. (123.19 cm x 101.28 cm). Bowdoin College Museum of Art, Bequest of the Honorable James Bowdoin III, 1813.55
Among the artists coming and going in the seaport, Moses Pierce (ca. 1783–ca. 1844) was unusually enterprising between 1815 and 1818. Pierce’s early career from 1806 to 1812 is recorded in Quebec, where he worked as a coach and sign painter. He returned to the United States in 1812, probably at the outbreak of the war when Americans were ordered to leave Canada. He advertised in Portland in October 1815, seeking patronage for his portraits, worked in oil colors, and expected “to tarry here for a short time.”32 In 1817, Pierce disappeared from the published notices, as many itinerant artists do. However, when he reappeared in 1818, he made an unusual announcement. He had been away, “having spent the past year in studying the most celebrated Paintings in the Gallery of Bowdoin College.”33 James Bowdoin III, a retired diplomat, had assembled an art collection comprised of over seventy European and American paintings, which he bequeathed to Bowdoin College in 1811. They were on view in Massachusetts Hall, the first college building, by 1813. A three-story brick structure crowned by a cupola, it is depicted in the earliest known view of the campus by John G. Brown (d. 1858) (Fig. 21). Works that Pierce would have seen ranged from European Old Masters to those by living American artists. For example, a painting attributed to the Flemish artist Frans Francken III (1607–1667), Achilles at the Court of Lycomedes, ca. 1650, was exhibited along with the 1805–1807 portrait of Thomas Jefferson by Gilbert Stuart (1755–1828) (Figs. 22 & 23).
John Smibert, The Continence of Scipio, ca. 1719–1722
Fig. 24 John Smibert, The Continence of Scipio, ca. 1719–1722. Oil on canvas, 45 3/4 in. x 62 5/8 in. (116.21 cm x 159.07 cm). Bowdoin College Museum of Art, Bequest of the Honorable James Bowdoin III, 1813.10

Another notable work was the copy of Nicholas Poussin’s Continence of Scipio of 1640 by John Smibert (active in America, 1728–1751) (Fig. 24). The painting tells the story of the Roman general Scipio who, despite his fabled lasciviousness, returned a captive to her fiancé rather than enslaving her. Providing a meaningful example of gracious leadership, the painting was likely used to instruct students academically, artistically, and morally in the early years of the college. Born in Scotland, Smibert trained in London, traveled in Europe and to Bermuda, and finally settled in Boston in 1729. He became the first professionally trained portraitist in the American colonies. Copying Old Masters had been a vital component of an artist's education since the Renaissance, and Smibert copied Poussin's celebrated 1640 painting while studying in England. He is known to have assembled Old Master drawings and paintings that he brought to Boston when he emigrated. After Smibert’s death in 1751, his family kept much of the collection intact in his studio where it continued to inspire American artists, including John Singleton Copley and Washington Allston. James Bowdoin III purchased part of Smibert’s collection in the late eighteenth century and with his bequest to the College established one of the first public art collections in America.34

Remarkable works by American artists also graced Massachusetts Hall, including Bowdoin’s family portraits by Robert Feke (active 1741–1750) and Joseph Blackburn (active in America 1754–1763). James Bowdoin’s gift of major works by Gilbert Stuart included the companion portrait to Thomas Jefferson, then president of the United States–that of James Madison, his secretary of State. Possessing a keen intellect and prodigious talent, Stuart studied under Benjamin West in England in the late 1770s. On his return to America, he gained fame for his state portraits of Washington and other American leaders. Bowdoin commissioned the portraits of Jefferson and Madison circa 1805–1807. Jefferson had appointed Bowdoin America’s diplomat in Spain, where he planned to use the large pictures in his formal reception rooms. However, Stuart was slow to finish the portraits, and, when Bowdoin’s tenure was cut short by the Napoleonic Wars, the portraits remained in Boston.35 Since their arrival in Brunswick in 1813, they have remained treasures of the Bowdoin College collection.

Moses Pierce, Susanna West Sweetser, 1819
Fig. 25 Moses Pierce, Susanna West Sweetser, 1819. Oil on canvas on masonite, 22.4 x 19.5 in. (56.9 x 49.5 cm). New Hampshire Historical Society, 1947.001.02
Having copied many of these works, Moses Pierce displayed his “collection of Paintings” at the Portland Bank where Alexander Parris's design provided spacious accommodations (see Fig. 4). Pierce’s “Gallery of Paintings” is the earliest known reference to a Portland artist operating a commercial art gallery. His paintings were on view for two months; he then moved them to his house, where they remained available for the public to see.36 He still offered his services for oil portraits, ranging in price from $30 to $100, the upper price being what Gilbert Stuart, America’s premier portraitist, charged.37 Perhaps discouraged by the level of interest by Portlanders (were his prices too high?), Pierce soon sought patronage in other towns, including Portsmouth, New Hampshire; Providence, Rhode Island; and Hartford, Connecticut. Depictions of his Portland sitters have not been identified. Fortunately, Pierce’s New England work is known through a portrait of Susanna West Sweetser (1786–1861), of Portsmouth, New Hampshire, signed and dated 1819 (Fig. 25).38 He worked in a distinctive style with soft features and delicate details.
Attributed to Rufus Porter, Hannah Lane, ca. 1815–17
Fig. 27 Attributed to Rufus Porter, Hannah Lane, ca. 1815–17. Watercolor on paper and graphite, sheet: 3 3/4 × 2 1/2 in. (9.52 × 6.35 cm). Private Collection.
Attributed to Rufus Porter, Benjamin Lane, ca. 1815–17
Fig. 26 Attributed to Rufus Porter, Benjamin Lane, ca. 1815–17. Watercolor on paper and graphite, sheet: 3 3/4 × 2 1/2 in. (9.52 × 6.35 cm). Private Collection.
Attributed to Rufus Porter, Jacob Davis, about 1815–19
Fig. 28 Attributed to Rufus Porter, Jacob Davis, about 1815–19. Graphite and watercolor on paper, sheet: 4 9/16 x 3 1/8 in. (11.6 x 7.9 cm) Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 60.852
Attributed to Rufus Porter, Thomas Long, ca. 1815–17
Fig. 29 Attributed to Rufus Porter, Thomas Long, ca. 1815–17. Watercolor on paper and graphite, sheet: 3 3/8 × 2 9/16 in. (8.57 × 6.51 cm). Bowdoin College Museum of Art, Brunswick, Me., gift of Julie Lindberg, 2016.45. Image courtesy of the Williamstown Conservation Center, Williamstown, Mass.
Attributed to Rufus Porter, Betsey Long, ca. 1815-1817
Fig. 30 Attributed to Rufus Porter, Betsey Long, ca. 1815-1817. Watercolor on paper and graphite, overall: 6 7/8 x 5 3/4 in. (17.5 x 14.6 cm). Rufus Porter Museum of Art and Ingenuity, Bridgton, Maine.

All this artistic activity must have inspired and encouraged Porter, a naturally gifted painter, to take-up his brush and give small watercolor portraits a try. He also had a family to support; he married Eunice Twombly (1794–1848) in October 1815 and their first child Stephen Twombly Porter was born the next summer.39 Miniatures of Maine sitters attributed to Rufus Porter were first identified in 2007, when portraits of Benjamin Lane (1777–1846), his wife Hannah (1780–1867), and a child were sold at an estate auction (Figs. 26 & 27). Porter’s earliest known family group, the Lanes lived in Minot, a farming community north of Portland. With one backboard inscribed “Rufus Porter” in chalk, art historian Deborah Child linked these portraits to the body of Porter work she was documenting.40 Her essay, “Rufus Porter’s Miniature Portraits: Practice and Patrons” in Rufus Porter’s Curious World builds on this research. Three additional miniatures of Maine sitters have recently been identified: Jacob Davis (1791–1864), Thomas Long (1798–1841), and his older sister, Betsey Long (1796–1867). Davis, like Rufus Porter and Benjamin Lane, served in the Massachusetts volunteer militia in Portland in 1814 (Fig. 28). One year older than Porter, Davis was a corporal in Captain Bridgham’s Company and Lieutenant Colonel Clark’s Regiment in Portland from September 1 to 24, 1814, at the same time that Porter served there.41 Davis also lived in Minot, like the Lanes. Thomas Long became an accomplished musician in the United States Navy; he and Betsey Long were from Buckfield, fifty-five miles north of Portland (Figs. 29 & 30). Porter deftly captures confident likenesses with his sitters exuding a special poise and vitality. Careful looking reveals details of Porter’s technique in these early works: a fine brown undulating line delineates the men’s ties and the ladies’ collars; broad color washes similarly appear on the dresses and coats; and fine striations create hair styles. Often, test brush strokes remain in the margins where Porter checked the color and viscosity of his paint. Remarkably, the reverse of all six portraits retain remnants of a cursive inscription in red ink, indicating they were likely cut from the same sheet of paper. Were they created about the same time when these mutual friends or acquaintances were together before returning to their hometowns? Four of the six works–the three Lanes and Betsey Long– retain their original grain-painted frames, likely the handiwork of Porter himself.42

One of Porter's last known Portland endeavors was the construction of his horizontal windmill. This project foreshadowed his later entrepreneurial efforts to promote mechanical invention through stock companies. Built on Green Street at the top of today’s Forest Avenue, the site of earlier windmills, Porter’s was completed in the summer of 1818. In this mechanical innovation, the mill’s sails, supported on a frame, moved parallel to the ground. Porter may have drawn inspiration from English examples, such as the one published in The Repertory of Arts and Manufactures in London in 1796. Merchant Bradbury C. Atwood, Porter’s collaborator, advertised shares of stock in the enterprise. The local press reported that the windmill successfully “manufactured excellent meal” and Porter later observed that it was “so constructed as to be manageable by a child of 12 years of age.”43 Porter honored his partner when he named his daughter, born that July, Mary Bradbury. However, after the mill was badly damaged in a storm, Porter was unable to repair or sell it. Discouraged by this reception, he soon sought greener pastures, relocating to Cambridge, Massachusetts, by February 1820.44

During nearly a decade in Portland, Porter embraced painting, invention, and publishing–three fields that he diligently pursued in the decades ahead. The town’s diverse and talented pool of artists, mechanics, and entrepreneurs not only helped him advance these interests but inspired him in his early efforts. Porter, like his notable contemporaries John Hall, John Neal, and Alexander Parris, found initial patronage, honed his skills, and developed the confidence to move on to larger markets and seek new opportunities. With a new understanding of Porter’s life in Portland, it is hoped that continued research of his activities–and attribution of additional early watercolor portraits–will shed further light on the depth and influences of his Maine experiences.


Image Image Image

Acknowledgements

Sincere thanks are extended to Jamie Kingman Rice, director of collections and research; Nicholas Noyes, collections librarian; and Sofia Yalouris, image services coordinator and collections technician, at the Maine Historical Society for their generous efforts and kind support. For further information on the Society and its collections, see www.mainehistory.org and mainehistory.pastperfectonline.com

The historic newspapers cited were published in Portland, Maine, unless noted otherwise.

About the Author

Laura Fecych Sprague is Senior Consulting Curator at the Bowdoin College Museum of Art. She was co-curator of the exhibition Rufus Porter’s Curious World: Art and Invention in America, 1815–1860 and co-editor of a book of the same title, which was published in December 2019, on the occasion of the exhibition.

1 Laura F. Sprague and Justin Wolff, eds., Rufus Porter’s Curious World: Art and Invention in America, 1815-1860 (Brunswick, Me.: Bowdoin College Museum of Art in association with the Pennsylvania State University Press, 2019), 15-16.

2 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 15-17.

3 Rufus Porter, “Epitome of Experience and Practice,” Aerial Reporter 1, no. 20 (April 27, 1854), reprinted in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 121-124.

4 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 15; “Epitome, ” reprinted in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 121, 123.

5 Laura Fecych Sprague, ed., Agreeable Situations: Society, Commerce, and Art in Southern Maine, 1780-1830 (Kennebunk, Me., The Brick Store Museum, 1987), 46–48; Moody owned Dolland’s achromatic refracting telescope; see John K. Moulton, Captain Moody and His Observatory (Falmouth: Mount Joy Publishing, 2000), 20, 23, 30–31.

6 Richard Candee, “‘The Appearance of Enterprise and Improvement:’ Architecture and the Coastal Elite in Southern Maine,” in Agreeable Situations, 83-34.

7 Constitution and History of the Maine Charitable Mechanic Association (Portland: Bryant Press, 1965), 3. Porter was not a member but would have benefited from its mission.

8 Quincy’s election as tythingman appears in Eastern Argus, November 24, 1810. “A Rare Mechanic,” Tribune and Bulletin, October 6, 1846, Maine Historical Society, courtesy of Earle G. Shettleworth Jr. “Epitome, ” reprinted in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 122-23.

9 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 16; see also Joseph W. Porter, A Genealogy of the Descendants of Richard Porter, Who Settled at Weymouth, Mass., 1635, and Allied Families: Also Some Account of the Descendants of John Porter (Bangor: Burr & Robinson, 1878), 285-287.

10 Portland Light Infantry, Record Book, 1803-1811, Maine Historical Society; the page with Porter’s signature is illustrated in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 20; “Epitome,” reprinted in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 123.

11 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 19-20, 25-16.

12 Agreeable Situations, 36-37; respectively, Eastern Argus, April 9, 1807, and Eastern Argus, August 11, 1808.

13 Eastern Argus, December 10, 1816.

14 The McLellan portrait is in the collection of the Portland Museum of Art, 1972.71.

15 See n37 below; Agreeable Situations, 123-124; the discount appears in his advertisement, Portland Gazette, March 29, 1802. The likeness of Stephen Longfellow has been attributed to Roberts since it was published in 1987, see John Mayer and William David Barry, “A City Awakens: The Arts and Artists of Early 19th century Portland,” Maine Historical Society online exhibit: www.mainehistory.org

16 Agreeable Situations, 207-208. Skilled and day laborers earned one dollar per day. Twenty-five cents would have been less significant for a professional or member of the merchant class.

17 Others included Reverend Samuel Deane and Eunice Pearson Deane, his wife; see Agreeable Situations, 89-91.

18 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 60.

19 Henry Cole Quinby, Genealogical History of the Quinby (Quimby) Family in England and America (New York, N.Y., 1915), 286-289.

20 Agreeable Situations, 91-92; Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 57-58.

21 Agreeable Situations, 48-49.

22 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 16, 26-27.

23 Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, “‘From the Fair to The Brave’: Spheres of Womanhood in Federal Maine,” in Agreeable Situations, 222-223.

24 Benjamin Lease, That Wild Fellow John Neal and the Literary Revolution (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1972), 11; John Neal, Wandering Recollections of a Somewhat Busy Life: An Autobiography (Boston: Roberts Brothers, 1869), 38, 132, 185; Portland Gazette, April 29, 1811.

25 Neal’s Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine reviews from August 1824 to February 1825 are reprinted in Harold Edward Dickson, Observations on American Art: Selections from the Writings of John Neal (1793–1876) (State College: Pennsylvania State College, 1943), 26–37.

26 Joyce Butler, “Rising Like a Phoenix: Commerce in Southern Maine, 1775–1830,” in Agreeable Situations, 27–28, 52–53. Kenneth Thompson, an historian of Portland’s early forts, kindly assisted with this research. He argues that although Fort McHenry in Baltimore is more famous, the Portland forts were important deterrents at keeping the British at bay. Jamie Rice at the Maine Historical Society also shared helpful insights. “Epitome, ” reprinted in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 123; Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 19, n48.

27 Agreeable Situations, 53-54. A description of the procession appeared in Eastern Argus, September 9, 1813. See also Candace Kanes, “Enemies at Sea, Companions in Death,” www.mainememory.net

28 Rufus Porter to Charles Norris, February 16, 1815, Baldwin, Me., with January 24, 1815, copyright notice, and Amos Cook to Charles Norris, September 24, 1812, Charles Norris Papers, Mss. 11, New England Historic Genealogical Society. See also Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 21-22, 24.

29 Abel Bowen, The Naval Monument: Containing Official and Other Accounts of All the Battles Fought Between the Navies of the United States and Great Britain During the Late War(Boston, Mass.: Abel Bowen, 1816). Within weeks of its publication, Portland booksellers advertised it for sale; see Portland Gazette and Maine Advertiser, June 25, 1816. For Bowen-Porter collaborations, see Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 26-28.

30 Agreeable Situations, 208-209.

31 Seth Clark, Business Ledger, 1815-1834, Maine Historical Society, Coll. 4061; Elder Family Papers, 1750-1805, Maine Historical Society, Coll. S-1871.

32 William David Barry kindly brought Moses Pierce’s activities to the author's attention. William David Barry, “Artists at Portland, Maine, 1784-1835: An Updated List of That Compiled for the Portland Museum of Art, 1976” (Maine Historical Society, typescript, 2007), n.p.; Lydia Foy, “New England and New York Portrait Makers in Canada, 1760-1860,” in Painting and Portrait Making in the American Northeast, ed. Peter Benes and Jane Montague Benes, Dublin Seminar for New England Folklife Annual Proceedings (Boston: Boston University, 1994), 114-115; Eastern Argus, October 11, 1815.

33 Eastern Argus, October 6, 1818.

34 Richard H. Saunders, John Smibert: Colonial America’s Portrait Painter (New Haven, Ct., Yale University Press, and the Barra Foundation, 1995), 210-211; Susan E. Wegner, “Copies and Education: James Bowdoin’s Painting Collection in the Life of the College,” in The Legacy of James Bowdoin III (Brunswick, Me.: Bowdoin College Museum of Art, 1994), 141-142.

35 Marvin Sadik, Colonial and Federal Portraits at Bowdoin College (Brunswick, Me.: Bowdoin College Museum of Art, 1966), 164-166. Charles C. Calhoun, A Small College in Maine: Two Hundred Years of Bowdoin (Brunswick, Me.: Bowdoin College, 1993), 53, 111-112.

36 Respectively, Eastern Argus, October 6, 1818; Eastern Argus, December 8, 1818. Unfortunately, Pierce’s copies have not been identified.

37 Stuart charged $100 for a 30-by-25-inch portrait, see Carrie Rebora Barratt and Ellen G. Miles, Gilbert Stuart (New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2004), 204.

38 For more information, see www.nhhistory.org

39 Joseph C. Anderson, comp., “Portland, Maine, Marriage Intentions, 1814–1837,” Maine Genealogist 30, no. 1 (February 2008): 36; Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 21.

40 “Lane Family Register,” watercolor and ink on paper, Private Collection. Deborah M. Child, “Thank Goodness for Granny Notes: Rufus Porter and His New England Sitters,” Antiques and Fine Arts (Summer/Autumn 2010): 190–95.

41 Gardner W. Pearson, comp., Records of the Massachusetts Volunteer Militia Called Out by the Governor of Massachusetts to Suppress a Threatened Invasion During the War of 1812 (Boston: Wright and Potter, 1913), 175. Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 19, n48. Other Porter-attributed portraits with related details have been found in a private collection but, unfortunately, their sitters are not identified.

42 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 22-23; Alfred Cole and Charles F. Whitman, History of Buckfield, Oxford County, Maine (Lewiston: Journal Printshop, 1915), 619. Unfortunately, Thomas’s miniature was cut down later for a smaller frame. For examples of the brush testing, see Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 67-69.

43 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 12, 23; respectively, Portland Gazette, July 7, 1818; Hallowell Gazette (Me.), July 29, 1818.

44 Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 23. Porter’s first known advertisement for miniature painting appeared in the Middlesex Gazette (Concord, Mass.), February 5, 1820; he charged two dollars for likenesses that took ten minutes to complete. It is reproduced in Deborah M. Child, “Rufus Porter’s Miniature Portraits: Practice and Patrons,” in Rufus Porter’s Curious World, 69.

More Essays